How to Find What Your Property Is Actually Worth
Where to look for property value estimates
Fair market value is what a buyer would pay and a seller would accept for your property in normal market conditions — not a forced sale or a distressed buyer. You can find estimates through three main routes: public records databases, real estate websites, and professional appraisals.
Public records are free and available to anyone. County assessor offices maintain records of recent sales, property characteristics, and assessed values. You can search these online through your county's website or through aggregator sites like Zillow, Redfin, or Trulia, which pull data from public records and display it alongside their own estimates.
Real estate websites calculate estimates using algorithms that compare your property to recent sales of similar homes in your area. These estimates — called automated valuation models or AVMs — update frequently and cost nothing to view. The trade-off is that they are estimates only, not appraisals, and they can miss details that affect value, like a recent renovation or a property's condition.
Key Takeaways
- County assessor records and real estate websites provide free estimates based on recent sales of similar properties, though these are starting points, not final values.
- A professional appraisal costs $300 to $500 but is the most accurate method and is required by lenders before they will finance a purchase.
- Comparable sales — homes similar in size, age, location, and condition that sold recently — are the foundation of any value estimate, whether automated or manual.
- Your property's condition, recent upgrades, lot size, and proximity to schools or transit affect value more than the estimate algorithms typically account for.
- Fair market value varies by what you are using it for: tax assessment, insurance, a sale, or refinancing may each require a different type of valuation.
How comparable sales determine value
Every valuation method — whether a website estimate or a professional appraisal — starts with comparable sales, or "comps." These are homes that sold recently in your area and are similar to yours in size, age, condition, lot size, and location. The more recent the sale and the closer the match, the more weight it carries.
When you search a real estate website, you can see the comps the algorithm used. Look at the sale dates, sale prices, and how closely each property matches yours. If most comps sold six months ago and the market has shifted, the estimate may be outdated. If the comps are significantly larger or smaller, in better or worse condition, or in a different neighborhood, the estimate is less reliable.
You can also find comps yourself by searching your county assessor's website or a real estate site's "sold homes" section. Filter by your neighborhood, property type, and sale date within the last three to six months. Note the price per square foot for each comp, then multiply by your home's square footage to get a rough range. This manual approach takes longer but gives you a feel for what the numbers actually represent.
Professional appraisals and when you need one
A professional appraisal is an in-person inspection and written report by a licensed appraiser. It costs between $300 and $500 and takes one to two weeks to complete. The appraiser visits the property, measures it, photographs it, notes its condition, and compares it to recent comps. The result is a single value opinion backed by documentation.
Lenders require an appraisal before they will finance a purchase or refinance a mortgage. If you are selling without a buyer lined up, an appraisal is optional but useful if you want to price your home accurately or if you suspect the online estimates are wrong. If you are refinancing, the lender orders the appraisal and pays for it; if you are buying, the buyer's lender orders it, though the buyer often pays the cost upfront and recoups it at closing.
To order an appraisal, contact a local appraisal company or ask your lender for a referral. The appraiser is independent and works for the lender or the party who ordered the appraisal, not for you, so they have no incentive to inflate or deflate the value. If you disagree with the appraisal, you can request a second opinion, though lenders do not always accept it.
Tax assessments versus market value
Your county assessor assigns a assessed value for property tax purposes. This is often lower than fair market value because assessors use a different methodology and update values on a schedule — sometimes every year, sometimes every three to five years. The assessed value determines your property tax bill, not the market value.
You can find your assessed value on your property tax bill or on your county assessor's website. It is public information. If you believe the assessed value is too high, you can file a formal challenge called an assessment appeal or tax assessment protest. The process and deadlines vary by state and county, so check your assessor's website for instructions and deadlines in your area.
Assessed value and market value serve different purposes. Market value is what you would receive if you sold the home today. Assessed value is used to calculate taxes. They are often different, and that is normal.
Adjusting estimates for your property's specifics
Online estimates are useful starting points, but they often miss details that affect value. A recent kitchen renovation, a new roof, a finished basement, or a detached garage can add value that the algorithm does not see. Conversely, deferred maintenance, an odd layout, or a noisy location can reduce value below the estimate.
When you review an online estimate, look at the property details the website lists. If it shows your home as having three bedrooms when you have four, or if it lists the square footage incorrectly, the estimate is based on wrong information. Many websites let you edit these details; doing so will recalculate the estimate.
For a more accurate picture, compare the estimate to the comps the website shows. If your home is in better condition than most comps, add 5 to 10 percent. If it is in worse condition, subtract the same. If your lot is significantly larger or smaller, or if you have a desirable feature the comps lack (a pool, a garage, a view), adjust accordingly. These are rough adjustments, not precise, but they help you understand whether the estimate is in the right ballpark.
How market conditions affect value
Fair market value is not fixed; it changes with supply and demand. In a buyer's market, where inventory is high and buyers have choices, values tend to be lower. In a seller's market, where inventory is low and competition is high, values tend to be higher. The same home can have different fair market values depending on when it is valued.
Online estimates update regularly as new sales data comes in, so they reflect recent market shifts. Appraisals are a snapshot at one point in time. If you order an appraisal and the market shifts significantly before closing, the appraisal may no longer reflect current conditions.
If you are planning to sell, watch the comps in your area over two to three months. If prices are rising, you may be able to price higher. If they are falling, you may need to adjust downward. Real estate websites show price trends for your neighborhood, which can help you decide whether to list now or wait.
Using value estimates for different purposes
The type of valuation you need depends on what you are using it for. For a sale, fair market value is what matters — the price a buyer would pay in normal conditions. For a refinance, the lender requires an appraisal. For insurance, you need the replacement cost of the structure, not the land value. For property taxes, the assessed value is what matters, not the market value.
If you are refinancing, the lender orders and pays for the appraisal. If you are selling, a real estate agent will provide a comparative market analysis (CMA) based on recent comps — this is free and is part of the listing process. If you are buying, the lender orders the appraisal. If you are insuring the home, contact your insurance company; they may use their own valuation or accept an appraisal you provide.
Do not assume one valuation works for all purposes. A home worth $400,000 on the market may have an assessed value of $350,000 for taxes and a replacement cost of $250,000 for insurance. Each number is correct for its purpose.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do different websites show different values for my home?
Each website uses a different algorithm, different data sources, and different comparable sales. Zillow, Redfin, and Trulia may all show different estimates for the same home. None is "right" — they are all estimates. If they are within 5 to 10 percent of each other, they are probably in the right range. If they differ by more than that, look at the comps each one used and see which makes more sense.
Is an online estimate the same as an appraisal?
No. An online estimate is an automated calculation based on public data and algorithms. An appraisal is a professional inspection and written opinion. Lenders do not accept online estimates in place of appraisals. Online estimates are useful for your own information, but if you need a value for a legal or financial transaction, you need an appraisal.
Can I use an old appraisal to refinance?
Most lenders require an appraisal no more than 120 days old. If your appraisal is older than that, you will need a new one. Some lenders may accept a desktop appraisal — a review of comps without an in-person visit — which costs less and is faster, but you will need to ask.
What if my home's value dropped since I bought it?
Market values fluctuate. If your home is worth less than you paid, you are underwater on your mortgage if you owe more than the current value. This does not mean you have to sell. If you plan to stay long-term, the value may recover. If you need to sell now, you may have to pay the difference out of pocket, or you may be able to negotiate a short sale with your lender.
How often should I check my home's value?
If you are not planning to sell or refinance, checking once a year is enough. If you are considering a sale or refinance, check every few months to track trends. Real estate websites update estimates monthly or quarterly, so checking more often than that will not give you new information.