What Determines Your Home's Appraised Value
An appraiser estimates your home's value by comparing it to similar homes that sold recently in your area, inspecting the condition of your house, and accounting for features like square footage, lot size, and upgrades.
The appraisal is not a guess. It is a formal document prepared by a licensed professional who follows a specific method. The appraiser does not decide what your home is "worth" in some absolute sense—they estimate what a typical buyer would pay for it right now, based on what similar homes actually sold for in the past few months.
Your home's appraised value matters most when you are refinancing a mortgage, taking out a home equity loan, or selling. It also affects your property taxes in some states. But the appraisal is a snapshot of one moment, not a prediction of future value, and it can differ from what you think your home is worth or what you could sell it for.
Key Takeaways
- An appraiser compares your home to similar homes that sold recently nearby, so the appraised value depends heavily on what those comparable sales were.
- The appraiser inspects your home's condition, structure, and systems, and notes any major repairs or upgrades that affect value.
- Appraisals typically cost $300 to $500 and take one to two weeks, though the timeline depends on how busy the appraiser is.
- Your home's appraised value can be lower than the sale price you agreed to, which can block a refinance or require you to renegotiate a purchase.
- Market conditions, interest rates, and local demand shift what homes sell for, so an appraisal from two years ago does not reflect today's value.
How appraisers find comparable sales
The appraiser starts by identifying homes similar to yours that sold within the past three to six months, usually within a mile or two of your address. "Similar" means roughly the same age, square footage, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and lot size. If your neighborhood has few recent sales, the appraiser may look further out or use sales from slightly longer ago.
The appraiser then adjusts the sale prices of those comparable homes up or down based on differences from your home. If a comparable home sold for $350,000 but has an extra half-bath your home lacks, the appraiser might subtract $8,000. If your home has a newer roof and the comparable does not, the appraiser might add $5,000. These adjustments are estimates, not exact calculations, and different appraisers may adjust differently.
The final appraised value is usually the average or median of the adjusted comparable sales, though the appraiser may weight one sale more heavily if it is especially similar or recent. This is why appraisals in hot markets can swing significantly—if only one or two homes sold recently, those sales carry a lot of weight.
What the appraiser looks for during the inspection
The appraiser visits your home and walks through every room, checking the foundation, roof, siding, windows, doors, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, and electrical systems. They measure the square footage, note the number of rooms, and look for signs of damage, deferred maintenance, or major upgrades.
Visible problems lower the appraised value. A roof that needs replacement in the next few years, a foundation crack, outdated electrical wiring, or a flooded basement all reduce what an appraiser thinks a buyer would pay. Upgrades raise it: a new kitchen, updated bathrooms, a deck, or a finished basement typically add value, though not dollar-for-dollar with what you spent.
The appraiser also notes the home's location within the neighborhood—whether it is on a busy street, near a school, or backing onto a park—because location affects buyer demand. A home on a quiet cul-de-sac may appraise higher than an identical home on a main road.
Why your appraisal might be lower than you expected
The most common reason is that comparable homes sold for less than you thought. If the market has softened since you bought your home, or if recent sales in your area were distressed (foreclosures or short sales), the appraised value will reflect that. An appraiser cannot ignore recent sales just because you do not like them.
Condition issues also lower appraisals. If your home needs a new roof, has outdated systems, or requires significant repairs, the appraiser will account for the cost a buyer would face. Deferred maintenance—a leaky roof, old windows, worn flooring—reduces value more than you might expect because buyers factor in the cost and hassle of fixing it themselves.
Market conditions matter too. If interest rates have risen since you bought, fewer buyers can afford homes at the same price, so comparable sales prices may have dropped. If your neighborhood is declining in popularity or if a major employer is leaving the area, that affects what homes sell for and therefore what yours appraises for.
How market conditions affect appraised value
Appraisals are tied to recent sales, so they lag behind market shifts. If your area is in a hot seller's market with multiple offers on every home, comparable sales will be high and your appraisal will reflect that. If the market has cooled and homes are sitting longer, comparable sales will be lower.
Interest rates also influence appraisals indirectly. When rates rise, fewer buyers can may have access to for mortgages, demand drops, and homes sell for less. When rates fall, demand rises and prices climb. An appraisal done when rates were at 3 percent will show a higher value than one done when rates are at 7 percent, even if nothing about your home changed.
Seasonal variation matters in some regions. In cold climates, fewer homes sell in winter, so winter appraisals may rely on older comparable sales. In spring and summer, more homes sell and appraisals reflect fresher data. This is one reason appraisals can vary if you order them months apart.
What happens if your appraisal comes in low
If you are refinancing and the appraisal is lower than your loan balance, you may not be able to refinance at all—lenders will not lend more than the home is worth. You can ask for a reconsideration of value (ROV), which asks the appraiser to review their work, but this rarely changes the result if the appraisal was done correctly.
If you are buying and the appraisal is lower than the sale price you agreed to, you have a few options. You can renegotiate the price down with the seller, put down more cash to cover the gap, or walk away if your loan contract includes an appraisal contingency. Many purchase contracts do include this protection, which lets you back out if the appraisal does not support the price.
If you are selling, a low appraisal from a buyer's lender does not directly affect you, but it may signal that your asking price is too high. If multiple appraisals come in low, you may need to lower your price to attract buyers whose lenders will approve the loan.
The difference between appraisal, assessment, and market value
An appraisal is an estimate of what a home would sell for, prepared by a licensed appraiser for a lender or buyer. An assessment is a value assigned by your local tax assessor to calculate property taxes—it may be much lower or higher than the appraised value because it serves a different purpose. Market value is what your home actually sells for, which may differ from the appraisal because the buyer and seller negotiated, or because the buyer paid cash and did not need an appraisal at all.
Your home's assessed value does not directly affect its appraised value, though both depend partly on comparable sales. If your assessment seems wrong, you can challenge it through your local assessor's office, but that is a separate process from an appraisal.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does an appraisal cost?
A typical appraisal costs $300 to $500, depending on your home's size, location, and local market rates. If you are refinancing, the lender usually orders and pays for the appraisal. If you are buying, the buyer's lender orders it, though the buyer often pays the cost upfront and it is deducted from their loan proceeds at closing.
Can I dispute an appraisal if I think it is wrong?
Yes. You can request a reconsideration of value (ROV) if you believe the appraiser made a factual error—missed a recent upgrade, used the wrong comparable homes, or miscalculated square footage. Provide documentation of the error. However, if the appraisal is low simply because the market has softened or comparable sales were lower, disputing it rarely succeeds.
How long does an appraisal take?
The inspection itself takes one to three hours, but the full appraisal report usually takes one to two weeks. During busy seasons (spring and summer), appraisers may be backlogged and it can take longer. Rush appraisals are sometimes available for an extra fee.
Will my home appraise for what I paid for it?
Not necessarily. If you bought recently in a rising market, the appraisal may be higher. If the market has cooled, interest rates have risen, or your home needs repairs, the appraisal may be lower. An appraisal reflects current market conditions and comparable sales, not your purchase price.
Does a home inspection affect the appraisal?
A home inspection and an appraisal are different. An inspection is a detailed report on the condition of systems and structures, ordered by the buyer to understand what repairs may be needed. An appraisal estimates value based on condition and comparable sales. The appraiser does not see the inspection report, but they do note visible condition issues during their own walkthrough.