How to Pick a Cash Back Credit Card That Fits Your Spending
There is no single "best" cash back card — the right one depends on how you spend
A cash back card that works well for someone who buys groceries every week might be a poor choice for someone who travels frequently. The "best" card is the one that pays you back on the categories where you actually spend the most money. Before you compare cards, write down your spending for the last three months across these categories: groceries, gas, restaurants, travel, online shopping, and everything else. The card that pays the highest percentage in your biggest spending category will earn you more than a card with a higher flat rate everywhere else.
Most cash back cards fall into two types: cards that pay a flat percentage on all purchases (usually 1.5% to 2%), and cards that pay higher percentages in specific categories (often 3% to 5%) and a lower percentage on everything else. Flat-rate cards are simpler and reward you no matter where you shop. Category cards require you to remember which categories earn more, but they pay significantly more if you concentrate your spending in the right places.
Key Takeaways
- A flat-rate card paying 2% everywhere is often better than a category card if your spending is scattered across many different types of purchases.
- Category cards paying 3% to 5% in your top spending categories will earn you more money than flat-rate cards, but only if you actually spend heavily in those categories.
- Cash back cards with annual fees rarely make sense unless you spend enough to earn back the fee within a few months.
- The cash back you earn is taxable income in the eyes of the IRS, though most cardholders do not report it.
- Switching cards frequently to chase higher rates costs you time and can lower your credit score slightly each time you open a new account.
Flat-rate cards: simpler, but only if the rate is high enough
A flat-rate card pays the same percentage back on every purchase, with no categories to track. Cards in this category typically pay between 1.5% and 2% cash back on everything. The appeal is straightforward: you do not have to think about which card to use or whether a purchase falls into a bonus category.
Flat-rate cards make the most sense if your spending is genuinely mixed — if you spend roughly equally on groceries, gas, restaurants, and other things. They also work well if you travel frequently and buy things in many different places, because you earn the same rate everywhere. However, if you spend $400 a month on groceries and only $100 on everything else, a flat-rate card paying 1.5% will earn you $6 a month, while a category card paying 5% on groceries and 1% elsewhere will earn you $21 a month on the same spending. Over a year, that is a $180 difference.
Category cards: higher rewards, but only in the categories where you actually spend
Category cards pay higher percentages (usually 3% to 5%) in specific spending categories and a lower percentage (often 1%) on everything else. Common bonus categories include groceries, gas, restaurants, travel, and online shopping. The catch is that you have to spend enough in those categories to make the higher rate worth the effort of managing multiple cards or remembering which card to use.
A category card makes sense if you have one or two spending categories where you consistently spend a lot of money. For example, if you spend $300 a month on groceries and $200 on gas, a card paying 5% on groceries and 4% on gas will earn you $23 a month. If the same card pays 1% on everything else and you spend $200 on other things, you earn an additional $2, for a total of $25 a month. A flat-rate card paying 2% on all $700 would earn only $14 a month.
The downside is that category definitions vary by card. Some cards count warehouse clubs like Costco as groceries; others do not. Some count gas station convenience store purchases as gas; others count them as general purchases. Read the card's terms carefully, because earning a lower rate than you expected defeats the purpose of carrying the card.
Annual fees rarely make sense for cash back cards
Some cash back cards charge an annual fee, usually between $95 and $450. The card issuer argues that the higher cash back rate or bonus categories justify the fee. In practice, this is rarely true for cash back cards, because the percentage differences are usually small.
To break even on a $95 annual fee with a card paying 2% cash back, you would need to spend $4,750 a year. If you spend less than that, the fee costs you money. A card paying 3% in a bonus category and 1% elsewhere would need you to spend roughly $3,200 in the bonus category and $2,550 in other categories to break even. For most people, a no-annual-fee card paying a flat 1.5% to 2% is a better deal. The exception is if you spend very heavily and concentrate your spending in the bonus categories — but even then, the math needs to work out in your favor before you sign up.
How cash back actually reaches your account
Cash back is not automatically deposited into your bank account. Instead, it accumulates as a credit on your credit card statement. You can usually redeem it in one of three ways: as a statement credit (which reduces your balance), as a deposit to a linked bank account, or as a check mailed to you. Some cards also let you use cash back to buy gift cards or merchandise, though this is usually a worse deal than taking the cash.
Most cards let you redeem cash back whenever you want, but some have a minimum redemption amount (often $25 or $50). A few cards let cash back expire if you do not use it within a certain period, though this is becoming less common. Check your card's terms to understand when and how you can redeem, because the worst cash back is cash back you forget to claim.
Why switching cards frequently is usually not worth it
You might think the strategy is to open a new card whenever you find one with a slightly higher rate in your spending category. In practice, this costs you money and time. Every time you open a new credit card, the issuer runs a hard inquiry on your credit report, which can lower your credit score by a few points. More importantly, opening many accounts in a short time signals to lenders that you might be in financial trouble, which can make it harder to get approved for loans or mortgages later.
Additionally, each new card comes with its own terms, redemption rules, and login. Managing five different cards to optimize cash back across categories is more work than most people want to do, and the extra earnings rarely justify the effort. A simpler approach is to pick one card that works well for your spending and stick with it, unless your spending patterns change significantly.
Cash back is taxable income, though most people do not report it
Technically, cash back is taxable income according to the IRS. The credit card company does not send you a tax form for it, and most people do not report it on their tax return. However, if you earn a very large amount of cash back (usually more than $20,000 in a year), the card issuer may send you a Form 1099-MISC, which means you are legally required to report it as income.
For the vast majority of people, the amount of cash back earned is small enough that it does not trigger a tax form and does not materially change their tax liability. But it is worth knowing that technically you should be reporting it, even if you are not.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I open multiple cash back cards to earn different rates in different categories?
Only if you are willing to manage multiple cards and remember which one to use for each purchase. For most people, one card that pays well in your biggest spending category is simpler and earns nearly as much. If you do open multiple cards, space them out by several months to minimize the impact on your credit score.
What if I do not spend much money — is cash back still worth it?
Yes, because cash back cards have no annual fee and you earn something on every purchase. A card paying 1.5% on $500 a month in spending earns you $90 a year with zero effort. It is not life-changing money, but it is assistance programs you would not have otherwise.
Can I use a cash back card to pay bills like utilities or insurance?
You can, but many billers charge a fee for credit card payments that wipes out the cash back you earn. Check whether the biller charges a fee before you use your card. Paying bills by bank transfer or check usually costs nothing.
What happens to my cash back if I close the card?
Any cash back you have already earned stays in your account and you can redeem it. However, you cannot earn new cash back once the card is closed. Redeem any remaining balance before you close the account.
Do I have to carry a balance to earn cash back?
No. You earn cash back on every purchase regardless of whether you pay the full balance or carry a balance. However, carrying a balance means you pay interest, which will quickly exceed any cash back you earn. Always pay your full balance to avoid interest charges.