Why CD Rates Have Fallen and What That Means for Your Money
CD rates are low because the Federal Reserve has cut interest rates to historic lows, and banks pass those cuts directly to savers
When the Federal Reserve lowers its benchmark interest rate, banks immediately lower the rates they offer on certificates of deposit. The Fed cut rates aggressively starting in 2020 and kept them near zero through 2021 and 2022. Banks had no reason to pay savers more—they were borrowing money cheaply themselves, and competition for deposits was minimal because people were spending less and saving more anyway.
The Fed began raising rates again in March 2022 to fight inflation, and CD rates climbed in response. But they remain lower than they were in the years before 2020. Even when the Fed paused rate increases in 2023, banks did not cut CD rates as quickly as they had raised them, which means the gap between what banks pay savers and what they charge borrowers has widened in the banks' favor.
CD rates also depend on how long you lock your money away. A one-year CD will pay less than a five-year CD because the bank is borrowing your money for a shorter time. Right now, the difference between short-term and long-term rates is unusually small, which tells you the market expects rates to stay roughly where they are or fall further.
Key Takeaways
- The Federal Reserve's interest rate decisions flow directly to CD rates within days, so low Fed rates mean low CD rates at your bank.
- Banks lowered CD rates sharply between 2020 and 2022 and have not raised them back to pre-2020 levels even though the Fed has raised its benchmark rate.
- The length of your CD matters: longer terms usually pay more, but the difference is smaller now than it was historically.
- Shopping across banks and credit unions can still find you rates 0.5% to 1% higher than your current bank offers, which adds real money over time.
How the Federal Reserve's rate decisions flow to your CD
The Federal Reserve does not set CD rates directly. Instead, it sets the federal funds rate—the interest rate banks charge each other for overnight loans. When that rate moves, banks adjust what they pay on savings products within a few days.
Banks use the federal funds rate as a benchmark for their own costs. When the Fed raises rates, banks' costs go up, so they raise what they pay depositors to attract money. When the Fed cuts rates, banks' costs fall, and they cut what they pay savers. The relationship is not one-to-one—banks sometimes lag behind or move less than the Fed does—but the direction is always the same.
The Fed raised its benchmark rate from near zero in March 2022 to a range of 5.25% to 5.50% by July 2023. During that same period, CD rates rose from under 0.5% to between 4.5% and 5.5% depending on the term. That looks like a big move, but it is smaller than the Fed's move, which is why banks' profit margins widened.
Why banks are not paying more even though rates went up
Banks face a timing problem. When the Fed raises rates, banks immediately have to pay more on new CDs to stay competitive. But they also have old loans on their books that pay fixed rates—mortgages, car loans, business loans—that do not pay more when rates rise. So banks' profit margins shrink when rates go up, and they try to protect those margins by raising CD rates less than the Fed raised its benchmark.
The opposite happens when rates fall. Banks cut CD rates quickly because they want to keep the extra profit margin. But when rates rise again, they do not raise CD rates as much as they cut them before, because they are trying to recover the margin they lost. This is why CD rates today are lower than they were in 2018 and 2019, even though the Fed's rate is higher now.
Competition also plays a role. When many banks are offering similar rates, no single bank has an incentive to pay more. But when rates are rising, some banks—especially online banks and credit unions—will pay more to attract deposits quickly. Those banks have lower overhead costs and can afford to pass more of the Fed's rate increase to savers.
The difference between short-term and long-term CD rates
Normally, a five-year CD pays noticeably more than a one-year CD. The bank is borrowing your money for longer, so it pays you more to compensate for the risk that rates might fall and the bank will be stuck paying you a high rate. This difference is called the yield curve.
Right now, the yield curve is unusually flat. A one-year CD might pay 4.5% while a five-year CD pays 4.6%—almost no difference. A flat curve tells you the market expects rates to stay flat or fall, so the bank does not need to pay much more to get you to lock your money away for five years instead of one.
This matters for your decision. If you think rates will fall, a longer-term CD locks in today's rate. If you think rates will rise, a shorter-term CD lets you reinvest at a higher rate when it matures. But the small difference in rate right now means you are not being paid much to take the longer-term risk.
How inflation affects what your CD rate is really worth
A 4.5% CD rate sounds good until you remember that inflation is running around 3% to 4% depending on what you buy. That means your real return—what you actually gain in purchasing power—is close to zero or even negative if inflation stays high.
This is why CD rates feel low even when they are at their highest level in years. In 2018 and 2019, CD rates were around 2%, but inflation was also around 2%, so your real return was roughly zero. Today, CD rates are higher, but inflation is also higher, so the real return is still roughly zero. You are not losing money, but you are not getting ahead of inflation either.
This does not mean CDs are a bad choice. They are still the safest place to park money you need in a few years, and they beat a savings account at most banks. But it does mean you should not expect a CD to make you wealthy. It is a place to keep money safe while earning a little.
Where to find the highest CD rates available right now
Your bank is probably not offering the highest rate. Most large banks pay 0.01% to 0.5% on savings and CDs because they have branches and advertising costs. Online banks and credit unions have lower costs and can pay more.
You can compare rates across banks using sites like Bankrate, DepositAccounts, or your credit union's website. The difference between the lowest and highest rates for the same term can be 0.5% to 1%. On a $10,000 CD for one year, that difference is $50 to $100 in extra interest. On a $50,000 CD for five years, it is $1,250 to $2,500.
Credit unions often pay more than banks because they are member-owned and do not have to generate profit for shareholders. If you are a member of a credit union, check their CD rates before you shop elsewhere. If you are not a member, some credit unions let you join through your employer, your school, or a community organization.
What happens to CD rates if the Fed cuts rates again
If the Federal Reserve cuts rates, CD rates will fall within days. A 4.5% one-year CD could drop to 4% or lower depending on how much the Fed cuts. This is why locking in a rate now makes sense if you think rates will fall—you keep today's rate for the full term, even if rates drop.
The Fed cuts rates when it is worried about a recession or when inflation has fallen enough that lower rates will not reignite it. Right now, the Fed is watching inflation closely and has signaled it may cut rates in 2024 or 2025 if inflation continues to fall. But the timing and size of any cuts are uncertain.
If you are deciding between a one-year and a five-year CD, remember that a one-year CD lets you reinvest at a potentially higher rate if the Fed raises rates again, but locks you in at a lower rate if the Fed cuts. A five-year CD protects you against falling rates but leaves you stuck at today's rate if rates rise.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will CD rates go back up to where they were in 2022?
It depends on what the Federal Reserve does. If the Fed raises rates again, CD rates will rise with them. But banks may not raise CD rates as much as the Fed raises its benchmark, so even if the Fed goes higher, CD rates may not reach 2022 levels. The Fed's own projections suggest rates will stay roughly where they are or fall slightly over the next year.
Is it better to buy a CD now or wait for rates to go higher?
That depends on your timeline and your guess about the future. If you need the money in one year, a one-year CD locks in today's rate and protects you if rates fall. If you think rates will rise, waiting costs you the interest you would have earned. Most people do better by buying a CD when they need one, rather than trying to time the market.
Why do credit unions pay more on CDs than banks?
Credit unions are member-owned and do not have to generate profit for shareholders, so they can return more of their earnings to members through higher rates. They also have lower overhead costs because they have fewer branches and less advertising. If you are a member, their rates are usually worth checking.
Does the FDIC protect my money in a CD if the bank fails?
Yes. The FDIC insures deposits up to $250,000 per depositor per bank. A CD counts as a deposit, so if your bank fails, you get your money back up to $250,000. If you have more than that, spread it across multiple banks so each account is under the limit.
What is the penalty for taking money out of a CD early?
Banks charge an early withdrawal penalty, usually equal to a few months of interest. A one-year CD might charge three months of interest, while a five-year CD might charge six months or a year. The penalty is higher for longer terms. Always ask what the penalty is before you buy a CD, and only buy one if you are confident you will not need the money before it matures.